Do Cervical Collars Really Help?

Headache and neck pain image.

You see them on people all the time – those big stiff collars that keep someone’s head from moving. Usually people wear them after a car accident, a sports injury or a fall, for "whiplash" or a soft tissue injury to the neck. They look uncomfortable. More and more of us are questioning whether they should be used at all!

Many believe that short-term use of a soft cervical collar can be beneficial in the initial acute phase of an injury. However, continued usage causes the muscles in the neck to weaken because the collar is actually taking the place of those muscles. Some studies have even shown that the use of a cervical collar may actually prolong the recovery process.

So how should you treat a neck injury?
  • Get in to see us! The sooner proper spinal, muscle and joint function are restored, the better. Waiting lengthens recovery time.

  • Try to keep you neck moving in as normal a fashion as possible; this helps keep the muscles from stiffening.

  • If you’re inclined to use a cervical collar, limit its use to less than a week.

  • Perform stretching exercises that help support the neck muscles/joints.

  • Continue your normal daily routine and activities; don’t “baby” the injury.

Whiplash injuries can also affect the normal curve in the neck. A chiropractic exam can determine the amount of damage. While pain relievers and muscle relaxers may make you feel better, they won’t heal damaged ligaments, muscles and tendons. And a cervical collar can’t return the natural forward curve to the neck.

If you know someone wearing one of these fashion accessories, encourage them to call our practice for a consultation. We promise to give them the same high quality care you’ve come to know us for.

Dr. Massart Asks some important questions of interest to Green Bay residents - Chiropractor Green Bay Dr. Massart Asks...

What's the difference between sick care and health care?
Sick care is largely about relieving or suppressing symptoms. Health care is about improving performance. While sick care is about how you feel, health care is about how you function. Sick care is what you do to treat an obvious problem, and health care is what you do to avoid the problem and advance your well-being.
What's your plan to deal with drug-resistant 'super germs'?
Chiropractors have always been concerned with the indiscriminate use of antibiotics, accelerating the mutation of microbes that make "wonder" drugs increasingly ineffective. My strategy? Do everything possible to bolster my immune system through proper diet, rest, exercise, clean air, pure water and an optimally functioning nervous system with regular chiropractic care.